Why prospects ghost you after a great first call (and what to ask before you hang up)

Cover: why prospects ghost you after a great first call
Cover: why prospects ghost you after a great first call

You had a good first call. They said it was "really interesting". You sent a proposal that looked right. And then you heard nothing back.

This happens to almost everyone who sells their own expertise, and it usually has little to do with the proposal. Jen Allen-Knuth spent 22 years in sales and closed more than $50 million with Fortune 500 companies before starting her sales training firm, DemandJen. On episode 4 of the Going Sollo podcast, she explained what is happening on the buyer's side when they go silent, and what to do on the first call so it happens less.

Why do prospects go silent after a good first call?

Most first calls turn into a presentation. The prospect showed enough interest to book the call, and so the seller spends the time explaining how good the service is.

Meanwhile, the buyer is thinking about something else. Your way might be better than what they do today, but changing is hard. They would have to stop doing one thing and start another, make the case for budget, and get other people to unlearn how they solve the problem now. In Jen's words, the seller is talking about what happens after the change, while the buyer is thinking about the road to get there.

If nobody talks about that road, the buyer leaves the call with an open question: does it actually make sense to go through the hassle of changing right now? Sellers then hear "this is really interesting" and take it as a buying signal. Often it is just politeness.

There is a second reason, and it hits people who work for themselves hardest. When you sell yourself, a no feels personal, and so it's tempting to avoid asking questions that might lead to one.

What are the two jobs of a first sales call?

Jen splits a sale into two jobs:

  1. The prospect decides they have a problem worth solving, and that they're solving it now.

  2. The prospect decides you are the right partner to solve it with.

Most first calls skip straight to the second job. The seller shows why their expertise is valuable and why their approach beats what the client has today, but the client never decided the problem needed solving in the first place.

The competition is often the way things are done today. Jen's example: a company's training might be run by someone who has been there for years. Nobody loves the sessions, but he's on salary, so there's no extra cost and he isn't hurting anybody. To win against that, the client has to see how the current way is holding back a bigger goal they care about.

What should you ask before you hang up?

Before the first call ends, Jen asks a direct question:

"There's probably a lot of problems you could solve right now. Is this even a problem we're solving? Is it one we're solving right now?"

If the answer to either is no, she follows up with one more question: "Can you help me understand why?"

Sales doesn't control timing. The company might be about to reorganise, buy another business or roll out a new system. Once you know what's in the way, you can plan around it. If they're still hiring the person who would own the project, for example, you can suggest picking the conversation back up when that person is in the seat and pencil a date in.

As Jen puts it, buyers want to feel that you're organising your timing around theirs.

This also changes how a lost deal feels. A great seller loses about seven out of 10 deals, and a 30% win rate is excellent. The point of the question is to find out which deals you're going to lose early, so you stop waiting on people who were never going to reply.

How can you tell if a buyer is really interested?

Jen looks for three signals on a call:

Signal

What it tells you

A head tilt while you explain something

They're thinking about how it applies to them

Questions like "what have you seen others do?"

They see you as someone who knows their market, which means trust is building

They ask for the next step before you do

The interest is coming from them

The third one matters most. Pushing for a next step at the end of every call often leads to more ghosting. Most people are nice and don't want to hurt your feelings, so they agree to a follow-up meeting to end an awkward moment, then cancel it later.

Why do sellers end up feeling pushy?

According to Jen, pushiness comes from feeling unprepared. When a seller doesn't think what they're saying is enough to make the buyer want to change, they start applying pressure, and it gets worse when they can feel the deal slipping away.

Two things fix most of it:

  • Know the company inside out before the call. With AI tools, there is no longer an excuse for not knowing a company's goals and recent news.

  • Plan a conversation that is as useful for the buyer as it is for you. If you know the time will be worth it for them, there's nothing to push.

What should a first call sound like instead?

Jen suggests using the first call to share ideas with the buyer. Executives are less sure of themselves than they have been in a long time, largely because AI has made everyone feel behind, and they want to know what other companies are doing.

So rather than opening with your services, open with what you've seen. Her example for a company moving to larger clients:

"I noticed you're making this move up market. There's a couple of other companies I've worked with that were also making that move, and there's a couple of things that made that hurdle really high. I've seen them do a couple of interesting things around it. Are you open to hearing what I've seen there?"

That positions you as someone opening a window onto what others have done. It builds trust in you and in what you know, and that trust is what makes the buyer willing to answer the hard questions at the end of the call honestly.

Listen to the full conversation

In the full episode with Jen Allen-Knuth, she also covers the four parts of every cold message she sends to busy executives, how she uses Claude to run the admin side of her business, and why writing on LinkedIn since 2020 is the reason she has a business today.

You can also watch it on YouTube.